4
$\begingroup$

When I dropped a stone or a crystal onto the floor, can it be considered as erosion? What is the difference between rocks breaking due to natural disturbances vs human action?

Here is the stone/crystal I dropped

one angle another angle another angle

$\endgroup$
7
$\begingroup$

I'm assuming here that you're asking whether you can apply the term ‘erosion’ to the damage your stone suffered, rather than the damage your floor suffered. In this case, the applicability of the term hinges not so much on who's doing it as on what it's happening to. In geology, the term ‘erosion’ is usually applied to land surfaces rather than individual, loose bits of rock. For instance, the Oxford English Dictionary has:

erode, v.
2. Geol. Of the action of currents, glaciers, etc.:
a. To wear away; to eat out.
b. To form (a channel, etc.) by gradual wearing away.

Nichols (2009), more concisely, says

... erosion is the removal of regolith material.

Once your stone is picked up and taken into your house, it's no longer part of the regolith material, although the surface you took it from was itself eroded by the stone's removal.

In the literature, human influences aren't usually excluded when discussing ‘erosion’. For example, the term is often applied when discussing how footpaths are worn down by human use (see e.g. Coleman, 1981).

So, if your dropped stone chipped a bit out of your floor, you might try to claim that as erosion, but only if you're prepared to argue that your floor constitutes regolith!

If you want a geologically appropriate term for what happened to your stone, abrasion would probably cover it. Allaby (2008) has this definition:

abrasion (corrasion): The erosive action that occurs when rock particles of varying size are dragged over or hurled against a surface.

The use of ‘erosive’ in the definition perhaps doesn't make it entirely clear that this can apply to the particles as well as the surface itself, but it's easy to check that ‘abrasion’ is indeed used in this way in the literature. For example, again from Nichols (2009):

... sharp edges tend to be chipped off first, the abrasion smoothing the surface of the clast.

Responses to comments

Does this mean that when my stone suffers abrasion, it is now destroyed?

No, not at all. ‘Abrasion’ just means that some material has been removed from your stone by mechanical action. Of course it would be possible to abrade your stone so much that it was completely destroyed, but this isn't implied by the term ‘abrasion’ itself.

What would happen to the damage over time? Will weathering try to repair it?

In general, material removed from a piece of rock will not be repaired by natural processes. In some natural environments, new minerals may precipitate in a crack left by abrasive damage, but this won't happen to a piece of rock sitting on a shelf in your house :). In the natural course of the rock cycle, an abraded fragment of rock may eventually be ‘recycled’ rather than being ‘repaired’ -- for example, it may be incorporated into a conglomerate, or buried, melted, and recrystallized as a new igneous rock.


References

Allaby, M. (2008). Oxford Dictionary of Earth Science. Oxford University Press.

Coleman, R. (1981). Footpath erosion in the English Lake District. Applied Geography, 1(2), 121-131.

Nichols, G. (2009). Sedimentology and stratigraphy. John Wiley & Sons.

$\endgroup$
  • $\begingroup$ Does this mean that when my stone suffers abrasion, it is now destroyed? What would happen to the damage over time? Will weathering try to repair it? $\endgroup$ – morbidCode Mar 5 '18 at 15:11
  • $\begingroup$ @morbidCode I've edited my answer to address the questions in your comment. $\endgroup$ – Pont Mar 5 '18 at 15:26
  • $\begingroup$ I added images of my stone. Can you confirm that it is indeed abrasion that happened to my stone? How mutch damage did I actually cause? Also, some people referred to it as a crystal, would that be correct? I'm afraid I don't know what type of rock it is. – $\endgroup$ – morbidCode Mar 10 '18 at 14:13
  • $\begingroup$ @morbidCode If you dropped it and chipped a bit off, then that's abrasion by definition (see the dictionary entry in my answer). As to "how much damage" you caused, I don't know how you want this quantified -- the amount of visible damage is the difference between how it looked before and how it looks now. Maybe an internal crack formed, but unless you made before-and-after CT scans you'll never know. As to whether it's a single crystal -- probably not, though it's hard to tell with such a heavily rounded surface. $\endgroup$ – Pont Mar 10 '18 at 16:20

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.