In petroleum geology, why do we consider hydrostatic pressure and lithostatic pressure separately? Surely the pressure at any point, whether fluid or rock, at depth is simply equal the weight of all the fluid and rock overlying it? Hence why isn't pressure for fluids and solids equal at a particular depth?

  • Underground rock stresses are not two dimensional. In addition to the vertical rock stresses (in the z direction), there are two horizontal (or lateral) stresses (in the x & y directions). As to why lithostatic and hydrostatic pressures aren't equal at depth, because they have different pressure gradients. See the graph for Pressure/Stress Gradients. – Fred Oct 25 at 2:30
  • The difference between these pressures is important in glaciology since water is more dense than ice. See the diagram under "Controls on crevasse depth" about halfway down the page. – Keith McClary Oct 25 at 2:57

I think (but I'm not an expert on the topic) that your assumption is wrong! The pore fluid pressure and effective pressure exerted on the rock are not identical. And during log measurements, it is only the pore fluid pressure that is measured, $\sigma_\text{pore}=\rho_\text{water}gz$. As long as the water is connected through pores to the earth's surface and it is assumed to be hydrostatic (not-flowing), the measured pressure in the pores will create a pressure to push up the overlying water only -- the rocks will take care of carrying the overlying rocks themselves! If you'd drill a borehole, the water-filled column would be filled with water exactly to the earth's surface. The effective pressure on the whole system is then $\sigma_\text{effective}=\sigma_\text{lithostatic}-\sigma_\text{pore}$.

However, once a seal is formed (e.g., a shale formation overlies a formation), the pore water suddenly has to also carry the overlying rock formation! The pressure will then increase significantly, and the pore water pressure that you measure becomes more similar to the effective pressure.

The pore water pressure thus increased below a seal because it is stuck. Once you drill a hole from the surface to this formation, you allow water to flow freely to the surface, and it is clear that it is under overpressure with respect to the lithostatic pressure, because it will blow out!

See also this comprehensive set of slides: http://ocw.utm.my/pluginfile.php/1509/mod_resource/content/0/To_upload_OCW_Formation_pressures.pdf .

Your Answer

 

By clicking "Post Your Answer", you acknowledge that you have read our updated terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy, and that your continued use of the website is subject to these policies.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.